All simulations

Nine States

The Constitution is signed but means nothing until nine states say yes - and your convention is the hinge.
Get the Teacher Code - Free Already have the code? Go to your dashboard →
U.S. History / Government Grades 8-12 6 roles 60 min 1-2 class periods
U.S. History / Government Grades 8-12 6 roles 60 min 1-2 class periods
The ratifying convention of the fictional-composite State of Mercer, winter 1788, while real states ratify around it on a live national tally board.

The class is the ratifying convention of a hinge state while a live national tally board shows the other states falling. Federalist and Anti-Federalist floor leaders work adapted primary sources; three delegate blocs hold all the votes and can split. The escape from deadlock - ratify now while recommending amendments - has to be argued into existence, and the class's drafted amendments are revealed beside the actual Bill of Rights.

Get Free Teacher Access Already have access? Go to Dashboard

Class Time

60 minutes

Designed For

1-2 class periods

Roles

6 roles

Class Sizes

Standard (13-20 students), Full (21-30 students)

Learning Objectives

5 objectives

Standards

5 standards aligned

Where This Fits in Your Curriculum

This is the day after you finish the Constitutional Convention and the day before you teach the Bill of Rights - the bridge most courses skip for time. It is a natural Constitution Day run, and it covers APUSH Topics 3.8 and 3.9 plus the AP Government required documents Federalist No. 10, Federalist No. 51, and Brutus No. 1 in a single period. Students need to know that the Convention produced a draft in 1787 and roughly what a federal government does. They do not need to have read the Federalist Papers, do not need to know any state's ratification vote, and do not need the amendments memorized. The real lesson underneath the floor fight is that the Bill of Rights was the price of ratification, argued into existence by the side that lost the vote and won the amendments.

What Students Will Learn

Social & Emotional Learning (CASEL)

Aligned to the CASEL framework's core competencies. These are the SEL skills students actively practice while playing.

Flexible Class Sizes

Standard (13-20 students)
Every bloc student is a delegate holding one seat and casting an individual vote (a bloc can split); one group per floor team, plus a Printers desk. Small classes near 13 can let the teacher run the Printers desk from the dashboard if there are not enough groups.
Full (21-30 students)
Bloc seats become pairs or trios of delegates sharing one seat and casting one vote together; floor teams run 3-4 students sharing one device, and the Printers desk 3-4 sharing one device. Seat weights are unchanged - 13 seats; a majority of seats cast carries (7 of 13 when every seat votes) - no matter the class size.

How the Game Plays Out

Turn 1: First Reading
The pamphlets land in your hall
"Nine states must say yes before this Constitution means anything. Delaware already said yes. What will Mercer do?"
Turn 2: The Grievances
Answer the blocs, or leave receipts
"The other states are ratifying. Can any as-written argument satisfy a grievance card that asks for text this plan does not contain?"
Turn 3: The Convention Acts
Straw poll, motions, and the head-to-head ballot
"Ratify as-written, ratify and recommend amendments, ratify only on condition, or reject - which motion carries the convention?"
Turn 4: Consequences and Reveal
Your amendments beside the Bill of Rights
"Where did the rights you fought for actually come from - and who was left out of the liberty you were debating?"

Roles Your Students Will Play

6 roles across 3 factions. Each has different information, different goals, and different leverage. Click any role to see their background and what they are trying to accomplish.

Backcountry Delegates
bloc
Farmers, debtors, and veterans of the recent tax rebellion from the western counties. They came within an inch of losing their farms to state taxes collected in hard money they did not have, and they do not trust distant power that cannot be seen or answered. They hold 5 of the convention's 13 seats.

5 of 13 convention seats. A recent tax rebellion is still in living memory here. The county courts and the jury are the backcountry's only real check on a creditor or a tax collector. These delegates will trust text, not tone.

Goals
  • Come away with written guarantees of jury trial and a limit on direct taxation, not spoken reassurances
  • Do not vote yes for a plan that only promises your protections instead of writing them down
  • Split your own 5 seats honestly if your delegates disagree - a 3 to 2 split is a real result
Harbor Delegates
bloc
Merchants, artisans, and shipwrights from the port towns. Their livelihood is on the water, and thirteen states bargaining separately with Europe means their ships get pushed around. They want the union badly - but a union that fractures their own state is no bargain. They hold 4 of the 13 seats.

4 of 13 convention seats. The Confederation cannot build a navy or force a fair trade treaty. A divided America invites foreign powers to play the states against each other. But if the backcountry walks out, the harbor's own state splinters.

Goals
  • Secure ratification so the union can protect commerce and build a navy
  • Keep the backcountry at the table - a ratification that triggers a walkout costs you the union anyway
  • Split your 4 seats if your delegates disagree on how much risk to accept
Meetinghouse Delegates
bloc
Civic leaders, printers, and small-town lawyers who run the meetinghouses, the newspapers, and the county courts. They are not enemies of the union - several helped write the state constitution's own declaration of rights - but they will not sign a plan that is silent on the press and conscience. They hold 4 of the 13 seats.

4 of 13 convention seats. The state's own constitution already protects the press and conscience in writing; this plan does not. These delegates want the rights fixed in text and a lawful way to add them - they want to complete the document, not tear it down.

Goals
  • Get liberty of conscience and of the press written into the plan or promised through a lawful process
  • Be seen as the bloc that completes the document rather than the bloc that wrecks it
  • Split your 4 seats if your delegates weigh process against principle differently
Federalist Floor Leaders
floor
The floor leaders arguing FOR ratification. You are actors making the strongest Federalist case, not endorsers - your job is to move the blocs' leanings with evidence, and to hold the coalition together when the vote gets close. You carry the adapted Federalist Papers, Washington's transmittal, Jay's disunion warning, and the load-bearing Hamilton card against conditional ratification.

Your hand: Federalist 10, 51, 39, 84, 11, Washington's transmittal, Jay on disunion, and Hamilton on why conditions are rejection. Every argument you make must attach one of these cards.

Goals
  • Move the three blocs' leanings toward ratification using evidence-attached arguments
  • Defeat conditional ratification with the Hamilton card - a conditional yes leaves the state outside the union
  • Play the Madison turn: at drafting, ENDORSE the bloc amendments you would carry to the First Congress
Anti-Federalist Floor Leaders
floor
The floor leaders arguing that the plan needs written guarantees before it can be trusted. You are actors making the strongest Anti-Federalist case, not endorsers. You carry Brutus, the Federal Farmer, Patrick Henry, Centinel, Mason, and Melancton Smith - plus the two bridge cards (Jefferson, Massachusetts) that point toward ratify-and-recommend.

Your hand: Brutus 1, Federal Farmer, Henry, Centinel, Mason, Melancton Smith, Jefferson, and the Massachusetts ratify-and-recommend model. Every argument attaches one card.

Goals
  • Move the blocs toward demanding written guarantees before they are bound
  • Serve as drafting counsel: help the blocs write amendments that cite your excerpts
  • Steer the room toward guarantees without steering it off the cliff of a plain rejection
The Printers Desk
press
You run the presses. Each round you circulate TWO excerpts from a mixed stack into the convention hall. A circulated excerpt is instantly citable by the floor teams; an uncirculated one costs a floor team a visible beat to read into the record before they can use it - and moves a bloc's leaning less. You also hold a pressure card each round that you may serve or resist.

Two circulations per round. A circulated card is cheap ammunition; an uncirculated card is expensive. Your pressure card each round is a lever on the room. At the debrief you show what the convention never cheaply heard because you chose not to print it.

Goals
  • Shape which arguments are cheaply available by choosing what to circulate each round
  • Decide each round whether to serve or resist your pressure card
  • At the debrief, own what the convention never cheaply heard because you did not print it

Hand Each Student Their Own Sheet

One click on the teacher dashboard prints a dossier for every role - background, goals, key facts, and their confidential briefing - plus the primary-source packet and a vocabulary sheet. Print them, or save as PDF, so each student reads their role on paper instead of huddling around one screen. The app still runs the votes and the action; the paper just carries the reading.

Primary Sources

Every role includes real historical documents. Students read them because they need the information to make their case.

Federal Farmer, Letter II
Federalist No. 11 (Hamilton)
George Mason, Objections
The Federalist No. 51 (Madison)
Brutus No. 1
Summary: the ratification press war

Key Terms Students Will Learn

ratifyconventiondelegatefederalismFederalistAnti-Federalistamendmentbill of rightsenumerated powersstanding armydirect taxationjury trialliberty of consciencemotionstraw pollconditional ratificationconcessiondisuniontransmitprecedent

After the Game: Debrief Questions

  1. Whose fears proved justified? Look at where each bloc's grievance ended up in the actual Bill of Rights - what got written in, and what did not.
  2. What did ratifying and recommending amendments cost, and what did it buy?
  3. The Constitution meant nothing until nine states said yes. How did that fact change what happened in this room as the tally climbed?
  4. Mercer was invented so no one voted against recorded history. The real states on the board were not. Where is this fight - written guarantees versus trust in the structure - still running today?

Ready to run this in your classroom?

Get free teacher access in 30 seconds. No account needed - just a passcode that unlocks the full game library, teacher guides, and session tools.

Get Free Teacher Access Go to Dashboard